In the News:
Bill 9: To Reinforce Secularism in Quebec

Bill 9, An Act respecting the reinforcement of laicity in Québec, Quebec National Assembly, 2025-11-27.

The purpose of this bill is to reinforce laicity in Québec.

To that end, the bill subjects childcare centres, subsidized day care centres, home educational childcare coordinating offices, persons recognized as subsidized home educational childcare providers, educational institutions accredited for purposes of subsidies, private health institutions under agreement, intermediate resources and family-type resources to the requirement to comply with the principles on which State laicity is based.

[…]

Sometimes nicknamed laïcité 2.0, this draft legislation, Bill 9, is meant to strengthen the provisions of Act respecting the laicity of the State (Bill 21) adopted in 2019. It implements some of the recommendations of the Pelchat-Rousseau Report, tabled in August of 2025.

Key Points of Bill 9

  • Face coverings banned in early childhood education and care services and in higher education institutions.
  • Ban on religious practices (e.g., prayer rooms) in institutions where secularism applies.
  • Ban on “offering exclusively a diet based on a religious precept or a tradition” in such institutions.
  • Ban, for these institutions, on using religious symbols in their communications.
  • Ban on wearing religious symbols for staff in early childhood centres, subsidized daycare centres, and subsidized educational institutions. However, an “acquired right” clause grants an exemption to existing staff.
  • Subsidized private schools may not offer religious instruction during regular school hours. They are also prohibited from selecting students or staff based on religious criteria.
  • Ban on “the use of public roads and public parks for the purposes of collective religious practice without the authorization of the municipality.”
  • No-one may “prohibit, limit, hinder or disrupt a religious practice within a place of worship.”
  • The criterion for accepting a religious accommodation is tightened. With Bill 9, it becomes “minimal hardship” imposed on the institution, instead of the current criterion of “no excessive hardship.” Furthermore, such accommodations must not violate equality between women and men.
  • Repeal of Act to foster adherence to State religious neutrality and, in particular, to provide a framework for requests for accommodations on religious grounds in certain bodies (Bill 62), adopted in 2017.

A Few Drawbacks

  • Bill 9 contains no fiscal measures. Religious financial privileges remain.
  • The “acquired right,” i.e. the exemption from the ban on wearing religious symbols for existing staff, has no time limit.
  • Bill 9 creates a new Act to foster religious neutrality, in particular in the public space to manage collective religious practices, i.e. public group prayers. These events—spontaneous, without permits, blocking public roads and more political than religious—constitute a real problem, but the title of this law is poorly chosen. Public space does not have to be religiously neutral. Rather, it is civic space, that is to say, State space, where secularism, including religious neutrality, must prevail. Secularism should not apply to non-State public space.
  • According to Bill 9, the requirement for religious neutrality does not apply to an employee who provides “spiritual development or care service” within “the health and social services network.” This provision would allow religious characters to continue hovering around the dying in hospitals. A way must be found to protect these highly vulnerable people from such manipulation.

See also:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*