In the News:
Report of the Pelchat-Rousseau Committee

Pour une laïcité québécoise encore plus cohérente : Bilan et perspectives (For an Even More Coherent Quebec Secularism: Balance Sheet and Perspectives), Pelchat-Rousseau Committee, 2025-08-26.

The Pelchat-Rousseau Committee was mandated by the Quebec government to evaluate how well secularism and religious neutrality are respected in Quebec State institutions. The Committee has just tabled its report, which makes some fifty recommendations. Here are some of them:

  1. Merge and harmonize the law on State secularism (Bill 21, 2019) and the law which regulates religious accommodations (Bill 62, 2017).
  2. Inscribe the secular nature of the State in a Quebec constitution.
  3. Inscribe the secular nature of the Quebec State in the Constitution Act 1867.
  4. Specify that the principle of separation implies that:
    • there is no official religion in Quebec;
    • the State does not recognize any legal normativity for religious convictions, beliefs and affiliations;
    • the State must not base its decisions or actions on any religious conviction, belief or affiliation;
    • the State does not recognize, remunerate or subsidize any religion.
  5. Gradually end all fiscal advantages and subsidies granted to religious organizations, by repealing:
    • the advancement of religion criterion for charitable organizations;
    • advantages granted to clergy and other religious leaders;
    • exemptions from municipal taxation.
  6. Gradually end State funding of private religious schools if they do not respect the four principles of secularism.
  7. Specify that State employees must not perform any action of a religious nature during their work duties.
  8. Ensure that any program against religious hatred must target all religions, not just one or a limited set of religions.
  9. Specify that no religious accommodation may be granted which would allow a person to demand to be served by an official of one particular sex rather than the other, except where the service involves the health, sexual privacy or safety of that person.
  10. Specify that the principle of freedom of conscience and freedom of religion must include:
    • a person’s right of belief or disbelief;
    • their right to profess or manifest their conviction, belief or disbelief outside of their duties as a representative of the State; and
    • their freedom from any constraint forcing them to act against their own convictions or beliefs, to adopt a religion or to submit to a religious observance, directly or indirectly, through pressure or other means, particularly when the person is in a vulnerable situation, for example because of their age or their actual or perceived religious affiliation.
  11. Protect children against all forms of religious pressure in State institutions.
  12. Guarantee the right of all State workers to perform their duties in secular institutions.
  13. Extend the application of the State secularism law to early childhood centres and subsidized daycare centres.
  14. Require that a person’s face be visible in order to receive any State service.
  15. Create an independent body to ensure respect for the secular nature of the State.
  16. Require that municipalities adopt a policy to manage public religious events on their territory. (Thus, the Committee report does not recommend banning street prayers.)
  17. Immediately require that administrators of public health facilities respect their obligation to provide abortion care.
  18. End funding of anti-choice and discriminatory organizations.
  19. For the purposes of religious accommodations, replace the criterion of “excessive” constraint with that of “more than minimal” constraint
  20. Reject any religious accommodation which is incompatible with the four principles of secularism.
  21. Ban prayer rooms in colleges.
  22. Guarantee the right of universities to refuse to provide prayer rooms.
  23. Require that any religious accommodation involving children or students be granted only after consultation of the establishment’s administration.

The report occasionally cites the brief which we, Atheist Freethinkers (AFT), submitted to the Committee, as well as briefs submitted by several other pro-secular organizations such as the Rassemblement pour la laïcité (RPL), Pour les droits des femmes du Québec (PDF-Q), the Mouvement laïque québécois (MLQ) and Droits collectifs Québec (DCQ). In regard to the report’s recommendation no. 9, concerning fiscal privileges granted to religious institutions, the Committee quotes our assertion that such privileges constitute “tax discrimination against non-belief.”

Unfortunately, the Committee did not endorse our brief’s recommendation no. 8 in which we suggest modifying the phrase “freedom of conscience and freedom of religion” in order to distinguish religious belief from religious practice, as well as to emphasize the importance of freedom of disbelief. This last point is nevertheless addressed in recommendation no. 19 of the Committee report.

In summary, the Pelchat-Rousseau Committee report contains a large number of good recommendations, measures which are necessary to strengthen and consolidate secularism in Quebec. We urge the government to implement them.

See also:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*