2025-09-24: Letter from RPL to Minister Roberge, Religious Products
Publication Date: 2025-09-28
The following letter is an English translation of the letter (in French) sent to Minister Roberge.
Montreal, 24th September 2025
Monsieur Jean-François Roberge
Minister Responsible for Secularism
875, Grande-Allée Est
3e étage, secteur 500
Québec (Québec), G1R 4Y8
Subject: Religious menus in schools and childcare centres
Mr. Minister
The Rassemblement pour la laïcité (RPL or Alliance for Secularism) is concerned about the trend among some public institutions to serve halal menus[1]. Since last week’s news about French-language schools in New Brunswick serving only halal meat, we have been receiving reports of the same phenomenon in Quebec. Several schools and childcare centres in Quebec offer halal menus. The Pelchat-Rousseau report on secularism also reports at least one early childhood centre offering an entirely halal meat menu. A mother reported to the RPL the case of her school, on the south shore of Montreal, which organized a back-to-school party whose menu consisted exclusively of halal meat. Furthermore, school administrators often make this transition to halal on the sly, without informing parents, as was the case in schools in New Brunswick.
We fear that this trend toward halal—or kosher—menus may become systematic in public institutions. This must be stopped before the situation worsens, for several reasons.
Secular and Political Concerns:
- For public institutions, adopting food with a religious label (halal or kosher) amounts to selecting producers based on their religion (Muslim or Jewish), which is discriminatory and unfair to producers who do not identify with either of these two religions. This is contrary to the necessary religious neutrality of public institutions and their duty of equal treatment.
- To adopt a halal or kosher menu is not inclusive but rather exclusionary. Forcing citizens to consume religious products is a blatant violation of their freedom of conscience. For example, forcing a Jewish person to eat halal (an animal slaughtered according to a Muslim ritual and incantations) is no more acceptable than forcing a Muslim to eat kosher (an animal slaughtered according to a Jewish ritual). The same applies to people of other religions, or of no religion.
- The rule that Muslims should consume halal is relatively recent but continues to grow. While initially the halal label only applied to meat, it has gradually spread to include all foods as well as cosmetics and medical products, and even hotels, clothing, education and finance. Submitting to an escalation of halal demands can only be toxic for the social climate, accentuating Islamic segregation, social isolation and community pressures, the primary victims of which are Muslims themselves.
- The deployment of the halal market is an integral part of the entrist strategy of Islamist networks in Western societies, as has been demonstrated on numerous occasions (see for example the Rapport Frères musulmans et islamisme politique or Muslim Brotherhood and Political Islamism Report commissioned by the government of France and published in the spring of 2025.)
Health and Ethical Concerns:
- Stunning the animal before slaughter is essential to reducing the animal’s suffering. This is recognized in federal laws, but also by the Quebec Animal Welfare and Safety Act which prohibits cruelty to animals. However, the Safe Food for Canadians Act provides an exception for Jewish or Islamic ritual slaughter, WITHOUT prior stunning. This causes the animal increased suffering and distress due to the delay between exsanguination and loss of consciousness. Remember that halal slaughter involves cutting the trachea, esophagus and jugular vein, and allowing the blood to slowly drain from the animal’s body while it is still alive. Allowing this to be done WITHOUT prior stunning is a “religious accommodation” that cannot be considered reasonable given the excruciating pain and distress caused to the animal. Forcing primary school students or users of any other public institution to consume meat produced in this way is an attack on their ethical convictions and a serious violation of their rights and freedom of conscience.
- According to many professionals, the risk of bacterial contamination of meat is increased by ritual slaughter without stunning because, among other things, it increases the risk of regurgitation of stomach contents which can thus contaminate the cut of meat (see our article[1] in L’Aut’Journal).
In other words, ritual slaughter is of no benefit to the population, but instead has serious consequences for animal well-being and food safety, and constitutes a flagrant obstacle to the secular nature of public services. It is the state’s responsibility to protect citizens’ freedom of conscience by not imposing religious dietary standards on everyone. Other solutions exist to provide menus that suit everyone, without compromising our health, moral and secular principles.
Thus, was ask you, Mr. Minister, to act promptly to put an end to the imposition of religious products (halal, kosher or other) in public institutions.
We thank you in advance for your attention to our request and offer you, Mr. Minister, our cordial salutations.
Nadia El-Mabrouk
President, Rassemblement pour la laïcité (RPL)
[1] See our article : « Ce que cache la systématisation des menus halal » (“What lies behind the systematization of halal menus”), L’Aut’Journal, 2025-09-23.
This letter (in French) is also available in PDF format.


