Blog 150: Bill 21 & the Current Political Climate in Canada

This blog accompanies our press release of 2026-01-05, “LPA-AFT denounces the duplicity of CFIC which opposes secularism before the Supreme Court”.

David Rand

Publication Date: 2026-01-07

Bill 21 and the court challenge to it constitute the most important issue confronting secularists in Canada. This is not some secondary issue about which secularists may disagree. We secularists have a duty to support separation between religion and State, especially in the one place in the country, Quebec, where it is making the most progress.

An important part of Bill 21 is its ban on civil servants (in positions of authority), including schoolteachers, wearing religious symbols while on the job. This is necessary to separate religion and State, because a civil servant on duty is an agent of the State. If a civil servant wears an obvious religious symbol while on duty, then religion/State separation is violated. The ban does not apply to those receiving services. (The law also specifies that those giving or receiving civil services must have their face uncovered.)

Opponents of Bill 21 say that it discriminates against religious minorities, but that is false. In fact, it is an obvious lie because the ban applies to all religions. All persons in certain job positions, whether male or female, whether religious or non-religious or antireligious, whether Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu or of any other religion, or atheist, must refrain from wearing obvious religious symbols while on the job. But everyone has complete freedom off the job.

Banning religious symbols worn by civil servants and teachers while on duty helps to prevent proselytism. Wiktionary defines proselytism as advertising one’s religious beliefs or converting someone to one’s own faith or religion. It can take several forms. Its most direct form is to try to convert others, but it may be indirect, such as imposing one’s religious beliefs and practices on society and its institutions in order to obtain some degree of influence and power over that society.

Perhaps the most toxic and insidious form of proselytism is in-group proselytism, i.e. when pressure is placed on those who are already adherents of the given religion, with the goal of forcing them to practise it more piously or more rigorously. One obvious example of this is when Muslim parents or other adults try to force a teenage girl to wear the hijab, whether she wants to or not. One of the purposes of secularism is to protect the freedom of conscience of children and young people by sheltering them from the excesses of the community into which they were born and which they obviously did not choose. This is why banning religious symbols worn by teachers is so important.

Another example of in-group proselytism is when Islamists succeed in obtaining a prayer room (sometimes for Muslims only) in a public school, university or other public institution. This allows Islamists to put undue pressure on less pious Muslims to practise and pray regularly. This harms Muslims in general while promoting the agenda of political Islam. This situation would be similarly unacceptable if it occurred within any other religious group, but the reality is that the religion is usually Islam.

Banning religious symbols has no effect on religious belief, only on religious practice. Belief and non-belief are protected by guaranteeing freedom of conscience. However, that does not grant absolute freedom of religious practice, because some practices need to be limited by law in the interest of the public good.

In a 2019 article, CFIC dishonestly accused Bill 21 of applying “special treatment” to some religious groups, when in truth the law does precisely the opposite, applying the same rules to everyone.

It is important to recognize that Islam is the most misogynist of all major religions. Some strict variants even require that women wear a stifling shroud in order to cover the body completely when outside the home. One key strategy of political Islam is to promote and normalize the wearing of the veil anywhere and everywhere, a practice which inevitably conflicts with religion-State separation and is thus incompatible with secularism. By holding Bill 21 responsible for this situation, CFIC blames the law for the misogyny of the religion. One objective of Bill 21 is to remove such religious iconography from State services (including from the persons of State employees), i.e. to separate religion from State. This helps women resist the pressure to conform to such demeaning religious strictures. But CFIC opposes this, thus facilitating political Islam.

In 2021, CFIC announced that its definition of secularism would no longer include the principle of religion/State separation. On the contrary, CFIC’s “secularism” now implies only weak religious neutrality, a sort of “open” secularism (which is a form of antisecularism). How convenient!

Again in 2021, CFIC refused to participate in a public debate, proposed by LPA, about Bill 21. We reiterated our invitation to a public debate recently, 29th October 2025, but have received no response. Why these refusals? Do they fear being unable to justify, in an open debate, their hypocritical decision to take an antisecular stance?

Finally, in 2025, CFIC confirmed that it will indeed intervene before SCC against Bill 21. The fact that the organization failed to support religion/State separation in Quebec is already bad enough. But now, to actively fight against it is utterly unacceptable.

In Canada, especially outside Quebec, opposition to secularism in Quebec is often expressed in the most virulent terms (and yet polls show that many Canadians agree with Bill 21). Given the current political situation in Canada, such behaviour evidently results from a combination of cowardice and conformism. Kowtowing to Islamists is very fashionable, as is viewing religious and other minorities as monolithic, ignoring the diversity within each group. This allows Islamists to claim to speak for all Muslims, which they do not. There are many Muslims immigrants who support Bill 21, who left their native country in the hope of escaping from the control of such theocracies.

To be frank, the Islamist lobby has great influence in Canada because the Canadian government is a total pushover for the propaganda of Islamists such as that of the Muslim Brotherhood (see for example the ISGAP report We Stand On Guard For Thee? The growing influence of the Muslim Brotherhood on politics, academia, and civil society in Canada). Furthermore, Islamists regularly use various postmodernist ideologies such as intersectionality in order to advance their agenda. One obvious example of this is the role of Amira Elghawaby who was appointed Canada’s first “Special Representative on Combatting Islamophobia” in January 2023 and remains in that post today. Elghawaby vociferously opposes Bill 21. On a Canadian government website, we read, in a guide drafted by her office, the following hypocritical nonsense (while homosexuality in several Muslim-majority countries is subject to severe punishment, even death):

“2SLGBTQI+ Muslims: Canada’s Muslim population encompasses individuals who are both Muslim and queer. 2SLGBTQI+ Muslims navigate intersecting forms of discrimination based on both sexual orientation, gender identity and religious identity. They can suffer specific compounding exclusions of homophobia, transphobia, racism and Islamophobia.” (The Canadian Guide to Understanding and Combatting Islamophobia)

Secularists must not only call for Elghawaby’s removal from her position, but the position itself—a platform for Islamist propaganda—must be abolished.

Opposition to Bill 21 from Canadians outside Quebec is also motivated by long-standing ethnic bigotry against French-speaking Canadians, who are concentrated in Quebec where there is strong support for secularism. Again, this bigotry is to the advantage of Islamism and other right-wing religious ideologies.

My book Stillbirth, The Failure of Secularism in the English-Speaking World lays out extensive arguments in support of Bill 21 and its provisions. Some of these arguments are summed up in the video “Why We Support Bill 21.”

Recently (October 2025) Quebec adopted further legislation—Bill 94, An Act to, in particular, reinforce laicity in the education network and to amend various legislative provisions—which strengthens secularism in schools. Still more recently, draft Bill 9, tabled 27th November 2025, would extend secularism in several ways if adopted. For example, it would ban face-coverings in early childhood education and care services and in higher education institutions, ban prayer rooms in institutions where secularism applies, ban childcare staff from wearing religious symbols, tighten the criterion which permits religious accommodations, etc.


4 Comments on “Blog 150: Bill 21 & the Current Political Climate in Canada”

  1. I vehemently agree that a state representative on service duty must not exhibit any religious affiliations which includes in his appearance
    I also oppose Bill 21 because regulating the above through state laws is an unjustifiable government outreach and an ugly and impractical tool for doing that.

    The solution is not reinventing the wheel but to follow professional ethics. Any business has a written and unwritten code of professional ethics, which among other things includes apparel. It can be driven by safety, presentation to a client, or any other professional needs, considerations and social norms. For an on-duty government employee like teacher, policeman or judge, such a code must include not coming across as a visible member of a particular ideology/cult/religion.
    A policeman showing to work with Sikh’s dagger should be treated roughly the same as forgetting his badge at home; a high school teacher in burqa deserves no less rebuke than the one in yoga pants exhibiting a pronounced camel toe; a judge wearing kippah is as much of a doofus as the one wearing clown’s nose to a hearing (although I admit the latter to be debatable and perhaps even justifiable to be mandated by law as an essential part of judge’s attire – sarcasm).

    In the normal/real (aka non-government) world, not adhering to codified or implicit professional standards for conduct, apparel, etc. would typically result in escalating warnings followed by termination of employment/contract, whereas when managed by a Bill that situation would tend to linger and exacerbate until it turns into a heavy, ugly and lengthy legal matter. Professional code is a well-established practice, often governed by respective professional colleges, so there is no need to invent a law for which inevitably there will need to be a committee or extra judicial capacities to decide what’s vividly religious and what’s not, or other extra bureaucracy funded by the taxpayers. Any grey area would be tackled by a superior through softly reminding his subordinate to please step outside of that grey zone, thus making the process (alas, still not perfect and subjective) lighter, gradual and altogether more manageable.

    But the most important difference in the professional code approach vs. law, however, is that in the former the mutineer won’t be punished for “being religious” but for being unfit professionally. Wearing kippah strongly suggests that the judge does not understand what message he is sending to e.g. a muslim plaintiff. That in turn means the judge’s judgment is compromised, thus making him unfit for the job professionally. The kippah is just flagging it, but likely there are other signs of non compos mentis too. So, he gets fired on the grounds of being professionally unsuitable for the job – not for being a devout jew and exercising his “religious freedoms”. Same applies to the aforementioned teacher and policemen – religious or not, we don’t need loonies in those fields.

    The judicial system could still play part in escalation of any disputes through Human Rights Tribunal or whatever (with the fading hope that this institution manages to make itself useful one day), but the state won’t have to butt in for every pity matter.

    • Thank you for your excellent arguments in favour of Bill 21. It is indeed a matter of professional ethics. A person who wears a religious symbol (or political, etc.) and refuses to remove it on the job is acting very unprofessionally.

      However, there is a problem with your position, and it is a huge one. You want to have your cake and eat it too. You want to ban, but without banning. I remind you that we are talking mainly about civil services and public schools. How the hell can the State enforce professional ethics on its employees without some kind of legislation? You want a code of professional ethics? That is what Bill 21 is!

      Even worse, you evidently think that Bill 21 punishes people for “being religious.” Have you even read the text of Bill 21? It is not that long (http://www2.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/dynamicSearch/telecharge.php?type=5&file=2019C12A.PDF). Apparently you think that it targets religious people. It does not. The ban on wearing religious symbols applies to any person in the relevant job, regardless of that person’s religion or lack thereof, including atheists. The behaviour which Bill 21 targets is the unprofessional habit of wearing an inappropriate symbol on the job. Political symbols are already banned by the Public Service Act, http://legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca/en/ShowDoc/cs/F-3.1.1

      The idea that Bill 21 “discriminates” against the religious or that it somehow targets religious BELIEF is straight out of the playbook of anti-secular propagandists, especially Islamists. The bill does NOT target belief. It applies a modest, reasonable restriction on religious practice (i.e. expression, not belief) in some jobs.

      Even if you found another way to impose professional ethics on civil servants and teachers, something other than a law, I guarantee you that Islamists and other religious fanatics would accuse you of discrimination, xenophobia, Islamophobia, intolerance, racism and other sins, just as they are currently accusing the Quebec government.

  2. No, I personally do not think that Bill 21 discriminates against religious. But a fallacious argument can be and has already been made that does exactly that:
    1) a non-religious dude does not exhibit or care about his religious appearance and would have no problem complying with Bill 21;
    2) for a religious fella complying would be a much taller order;
    3) hence, the Bill targets the religious, and, voila, is discriminatory.
    It’s like complaining that the law against child molestation disproportionately targets pedophiles. Well.. dah! But that’s an effect – not the intent. I guess I don’t have to explain that to you, but one must be aware of the fact that sound reasoning isn’t in fashion nowadays.

    Bill 21 is bad because (as I already explained) it inflates the government and lets it into the area where it does not belong. Fighting evil/stupidity with bureaucracy might be the only option in this case (the lesser of two evils), which means if I had to only choose between a judge wearing turban and Bill 21 I ‘d choose the latter (even though it’s not a dichotomy).

    Ideally we need to eliminate the illogical Anglo model of a secular state, which will take care of the underlying problem and eliminate the need for special legislature. That’s ideally…

    But my solution targets professional code, which does not have to be implemented through legislature. We don’t have bills prohibiting clown outfits (and many other things) for teachers. Even roach Lecce made a reference to the code when engaging Ontario College of Teachers in the curious case of Kayla Lemieux.
    https://www.ctvnews.ca/toronto/article/teacher-at-centre-of-dress-code-controversy-no-longer-working-at-oakville-school/
    Whether embedding religious neutrality into colleges’ professional codes requires special legislation is a different question, but if it does then what about wearing oversized prosthetic breasts? Do we need Bill 22 for that?

    I haven’t worked for the government and my judgement of that environment with its rules and regulations might be skewed. But in my line of IT consulting business, if I were to walk into a client’s office wearing fins, my boss would make a fuss of me as not representing the company well. And my appeal that identifying as a Poseidon worshiping dolphin is not prohibited by the job description would merit a different kind of attention than I might expect.

    There must be a line where the law ends and common sense begins, but this line keeps receding, and Bill 21 helps it do that.

    • You write that accusing Bill 21 of being discriminatory is “like complaining that the law against child molestation disproportionately targets pedophiles.”
      Exactly.
      I have made a similar argument: Accusing Bill 21 of being discriminatory is like saying that speed limits discriminate against owners of fast cars.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Print This Page