Blog 152: How to Fight Against Secularism

David Rand

Publication Date: 2026-05-05

In the wake of the National Assembly’s adoption of Bill 94 (An Act to, in particular, reinforce laicity in the education network and to amend various legislative provisions, 30th October 2025) and Bill 9 (An Act respecting the reinforcement of laicity in Québec, 2nd April 2026), as well as the recent hearings (late March 2026) of the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) involving challenges to An Act respecting the laicity of the State (Bill 21 which the other two bills extend), we hear a plethora of specious arguments against these laws and against secularism. These arguments are not new. Many have been repeated countless times over the years. Nevertheless, it is worth reviewing them in order to understand them better.

Among these fallacious arguments, we find several types.

Blaming Secular Legislation For the Harmful Effects of Religion

This approach is very frequently used. A striking example is a recent article Dureté sélective (Selective Severity) by Émile Nicolas, published in Le Devoir on 30th April 2026. According to Ms. Nicolas, Muslim women who wear the veil are the “scapegoats” and “black sheep” of these laws and Muslims in general are thus stigmatized, suffering a “disparity in treatment.”

However, Muslim women who feel compelled to wear such demeaning attire are indeed discriminated against, but not by secular laws, rather by Islam itself. It is Islam, or at least a certain strict interpretation of that religion, which requires that women hide behind the veil under penalty of being accused of being a bad Muslim of dubious morals who deserves to spend eternity in hell. Here we have a conspicuous example of Ernest Renan’s famous observation that Muslims are the first victims of Islam.

Muslim women are indeed particularly targeted, but by Islam, not by secular legislation!

Secularism helps to curb this retrograde and hyper-misogynistic ideology in the civil service by imposing rules that apply to everyone in the relevant jobs, without discrimination. Secular laws apply to behaviour, not to people, nor to a particular religion. Secularism is a remedy for discrimination, not a cause. Muslim women are indeed particularly targeted, but by Islam, not by secular legislation!

By conflating Islam and Muslim women—that is, conflating the religion and the person who practices it—Ms. Nicolas distorts the debate by accusing secularism of the discrimination whose obvious cause is Islam. Furthermore, she reinforces this distortion by linking the situation to “racism” and “systemic discrimination,” thus essentializing religious affiliation as if it were an immutable racial identity and disregarding freedom of conscience.

Accusing Secular Legislation of Authoritarianism

Another strategy frequently used by opponents of secularism is to equate secular laws with authoritarianism. Here are two examples.

“the legislator has the final say.”

During his address to the Supreme Court, lawyer Frédéric Bérard attempted to link Bill 21 to authoritarian regimes in the United States, Russia, and China, alleging that the notwithstanding clause would empower “potential mini-Trumps here in Canada.” Justice Malcolm Rowe was not buying it, reminding Mr. Bérard that the very purpose of this clause (section 33 of the Constitution Act, 1982) is to allow elected officials to legislate in disagreement with the courts. Justice Suzanne Côté concurred, stating that “the legislator has the final say.” Justice Rowe then dismissed the lawyer’s allegation by posing the rhetorical question: Should we interpret the Canadian Constitution based on who is president of the United States or Russia, or who is head of the Communist Party of China?

It should be mentioned that this same F. Bérard made the extravagant claim that “there is clearly no link between religious symbols and proselytism.”

At AFT, we have received several emails from an individual identifying himself as a Board member of the Centre for Inquiry Canada (CFIC) and furious that we, AFT, have denounced the hypocrisy of his organization which claims to support secularism while opposing secularism in Quebec. His reasoning? With Bill 21, Quebec is following the same path as China! Keep in mind that China is a one-party State with a recent history of severe persecution of certain believers, including violence and imprisonment. Any comparison with Quebec is utter nonsense.

Muddling the Definitions of Secularism and State Religious Neutrality

Here are several indirect ways in which a cause can be undermined:

  1. Pretend to work towards the goal, but do so very badly.
  2. Redefine the goal (to something that sounds very similar but is not), then work for the redefined goal and against the original goal.
  3. Claim that the goal has already been achieved. Thus, there is nothing more to do.
  4. Claim that the goal is impossible to achieve. Thus, nothing can be done.

In Canada and Quebec, almost everyone claims to support secularism. But often, there is a big “but” that qualifies this claim, followed by a stance that undermines secularism, along the lines of, “we support secularism, but Bill 21 isn’t really secular.” A redefinition of secularism is adopted that is compatible with one’s prior positions (that is, with one’s prejudices), whereas the opposite procedure should be followed: first, establish a reasonable definition of secularism, and then examine one’s positions to assess their consistency with it.

A frequent implementation of this yes-BUT strategy is to abandon completely the notion of separation between religions and the State in order to redefine secularism as a simple synonym for religious neutrality, with all the vagueness and ambiguity that that entails, thus allowing pro-religious positions to be adopted.

This strategy can be observed in the brief presented to the SCC by the Canadian Secular [sic] Alliance (CSA) and the B.C. Humanist [sic] Association (BCHA) which, like CFIC, oppose secularism in Quebec. Their brief begins with the following very simple paragraph:

“Canada is a secular democracy.”

Given that the 1982 Canadian Constitution begins with a reference to “the supremacy of God” and given that Canada’s head of State is also the head of the Church of England, as well as for several other reasons, it is rather bizarre to claim that the country is “secular.” If Canada is already secular, does that mean no further measures are necessary?

It should also be mentioned that Canadian democracy is threatened by opponents of Bill 21 who seek to limit the use of the notwithstanding clause of the Constitution.

Religious interference in State affairs is apparently acceptable as long as all religions are similarly permitted.

The brief provides no explicit definition of secularism, but asserts that the State must remain neutral with regard to religion and must respect religious differences without seeking to “extinguish” them. Thus, the notion of separation between religions and State is discarded and replaced by an extremely weak religious neutrality, as the State must allow religions to manifest themselves, seemingly even within the State itself. Religious interference in State affairs is apparently acceptable as long as all religions are similarly permitted. Thus, CSA and BCHA do not advocate State religious neutrality, but rather State powerlessness.

Neither does the CSA-BCHA brief offer any definition of the concept of “religion,” even claiming that any such definition is impossible. It is also impossible and unacceptable, according to the brief, to define a religious symbol. Only the wearer of the symbol can designate its meaning. Paragraph 71 is particularly noteworthy because it declares that “Canada, as a secular state, is in principle incapable of distinguishing between religious, cultural, political, and other symbolism.”

If it is impossible to identify religious imagery, then it is impossible to ban not only religious symbols worn by civil servants but also those displayed on civic facilities, such as the walls of State buildings, schools, and hospitals. Furthermore, if it is impossible to distinguish religious from political symbolism, how can the former be permitted while the latter is prohibited, as the Public Service Act does?

The CSA-BCHA brief is totally incoherent—confused, illogical and antisecular.

The Hidden Axiom: Priority for Religion Above All Else

Behind these various anti-secular strategies, there lies, in my opinion, a common principle, an assumption rarely stated explicitly, but which remains nonetheless, an underlying notion that informs and fuels all opposition to secularism. This principle—let’s call it an axiom or a postulate, since it is very rarely questioned—is to grant religion priority over any other ideology. That is to say, it is assumed that religious belief is more important, more essential, more indispensable than any other belief, idea, or ideology; that religious faith is more important than political, artistic, scientific or other opinions; that religious morality and identity must prevail over all other considerations. If this axiom is taken for granted, then it becomes reasonable to prohibit political partisanship in the workplace without prohibiting religious partisanship.

[…] there is no justification for the preferential treatment that religion enjoys almost everywhere.

This axiom, however, must be challenged. In fact, it must be thrown out altogether, because there is no justification for the preferential treatment that religion enjoys almost everywhere. It is, in fact, an intellectual privilege granted to religions by tradition—because religion is a pre-scientific and outdated way of acquiring knowledge, as well as a moral system based on that dubious knowledge. This privilege must be taken away from religions, just as the goal of secularism is to revoke religions’ privileges within the State.

The ban on religious symbols worn by civil servants and school staff is perfectly reasonable; it makes perfect sense, for the same reason that discretion in the workplace is required regarding politics. A crucifix or a hijab is no more precious than a political party slogan or the image of a revolutionary hero.

All these anti-secular actors relentlessly denounce the supposed injustice of Quebec’s secular legislation. What they are actually doing is fighting to maintain religious privilege. And to all of them, the same question must be asked, and asked again and again: why demand political neutrality from State employees without demanding religious neutrality? Such preferential treatment is unjustified.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Print This Page