In the News:
Challenging Bill 21 before the Supreme Court
Retour sur la contestation de la loi 21 (“A look back at the court challenge against Bill 21”), François Charbonneau, Le Devoir, 2026-04-03.
“With its secularism law, Quebec is not doing anything very different from what the federal government already does in this area.”
“Those who oppose Bill 21 claim they want to preserve the ‘free choice’ of Quebec civil servants to wear religious symbols while performing their duties. But why do they want this? Because they believe it is important for an individual to live their life according to their beliefs. If the Supreme Being commands you to wear a symbol and you are prevented from doing so, it could cause you profound anguish, especially if you believe in the Last Judgment. You might even prefer to forgo a job rather than disobey God. For the detractors of Bill 21, one cannot set aside one’s faith, they insist, even for part of the day.”
“But if we take this argument seriously, on what principle can believers be forbidden from living out all aspects of their faith? The Canadian political system, for example, forbids polygamous Mormons or Muslims from fully living their dogma. The Quran, which, after all, contains the word of God according to its followers, allows Muslim men to marry up to four women (4:3). If living according to one’s faith is a fundamental right, why is this form of ‘polyamory’ forbidden to these men (or even women)?”
“In many ways, the federal government, through its constitution and laws, prevents believers who wish to do so from fully living according to the teachings of their gods. With its secularism law, Quebec does nothing much different, simply asking those whose salaries are paid by all Quebec citizens not to wear a religious symbol for part of the day, based on a goal of State neutrality that is widely supported by the population.”
Quebec’s law on State secularism is a very modest measure that imposes quite reasonable constraints on civil servants. Those who contest this law are completely mistaken. To be consistent, they would have to challenge all the other numerous laws that limit religious practice in one way or another. The result would be unbearable chaos.
See also:

