In the News:
Mayor of New York uses Islam to Support his Sanctuary City Policy
At Annual Interfaith Breakfast, Mayor Mamdani Reaffirms City’s Sanctuary Status, Launches Expansive “Know Your Rights” Push to Protect Immigrant New Yorkers From Federal Overreach, New York City, Office of the Mayor, 2026-02-06.
At an interfaith breakfast hosted by New York City, the first of what is expected to be an annual event, Mayor Zohran Mamdani reaffirmed that New York is a sanctuary city that protects immigrants, signing an executive order to that effect.
The City plans to distribute tens of thousands of leaflets, in some ten languages, to “faith institutions,” explaining to people targeted by ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) agents their rights and informing them about sanctuary services offered by the City.
During his speech, the mayor even made the following statement:
“And I consider my own faith, Islam, a religion built upon a narrative of migration. The story of the Hijra reminds us that Prophet Muhammad (SWT) was a stranger too, who fled Mecca and was welcomed in Medina… If faith offers us the moral compass to stand alongside the stranger, government can provide the resources.”
The Curious Ramblings of Mayor Mamdani
Thus, Mayor Mamdani places the immigrant’s religious affiliation at the heart of his strategy to oppose the American president’s immigration policies. In a country that claims to be “secular,” even boasts of it, this approach is frankly bizarre. But it is not surprising, because in reality, the American Constitution does not declare the separation of religion and State, but only a weak religious neutrality where religions can freely interfere in state affairs, provided that this privilege is granted to all religions. Moreover, the mayor seems to claim that religious faith constitutes the foundation of morality.
But what is even more troubling are the mayor’s remarks about Muhammad’s migration from Mecca to Medina. This is a pivotal event in the history of Islam—in fact, it marks the beginning, the zero point, of the Islamic calendar—where Muslim spirituality before this migration was transformed into a conquering, violent, and intolerant ideology afterward. Is this really what Mayor Mamdani wants to offer New Yorkers?


It is interesting how what Mamdani called “migration” was in fact a conquest that resulted in a creation of an empire. Destruction of local cultures in the name of religion “of peace” followed. One’s own innate conscience and compassion, not “faith,” says we need to stand by people who are unjustly arrested. But it says nothing about allowing newcomers to settle without proper vetting. The whole kerfuffle was caused by America’s insatiable appetite for the cheapest possible workforce. This created a porous border that became a magnet for people who look for an opportunity to cross into the US, but would never be allowed because of their checkered past. Then it became a political football where truth is lost to rhetoric.