The Question of Secularism in CEGEPs Must be Addressed

This letter was previously published in Le Devoir under the title Une réflexion sur la laïcité dans les cégeps s’impose.

Nadia El-Mabrouk, Fatima Aboubakr, François Dugré, Marie-Claude Girard, Etienne-Alexis Boucher, Raphaël Guérard, Lyne Jubinville and Lucie Jobin, on behalf of the Rassemblement pour la laïcité (RPL)

Publication Date: 2025-07-04

In the context of the war in Gaza, acrimonious demonstrations have taken place in several CEGEPs and universities in Montreal, leading to intimidation and a noxious climate. It was in response to several complaints that Pascale Déry, Minister of Higher Education, ordered an investigation into the situation at Dawson and Vanier Colleges (both of which are English-language institutions).

The resulting report, which has just been published, identifies student associations as the source of this toxic atmosphere. These associations act in ways incompatible with their own statutes. We learn, for example, that Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights Dawson (SPHRD) displays its participation in “activist movements of a socio-political nature,” thus contravening its constitution stating that the club must not be political in nature. Moreover, the investigators point out that the activities organized by these clubs do not in any way promote “understanding and camaraderie among all sectors of the community,” but rather create a dynamic of exclusion giving rise to tensions.

The investigators also observe the difficulty of distinguishing between “what is cultural and what is religious” in the activities of associations such as the SPHRD, but also the Muslim Student Association, the Jewish Student Association or even Islamic Relief, the last one being, according to several sources, a branch of the Muslim Brotherhood organization. However, if culture, or even politics, is at the heart of the academic vitality of CEGEPs, the same is not true of religion, which is a matter of beliefs and tends to compartmentalize people into different communities.

How can we be surprised by the toxic climate caused by this proliferation of religious groups, particularly in the context of the current war in the Middle East? This also has the effect of creating a climate of pious zeal in an institution that should be dedicated to learning, and is causing an escalation of requests for religious accommodations, putting undue pressure on the administrators of colleges and CEGEPs and on some students.

The report also indicates that exams and educational activities are arranged according to various religious holidays. There is even a prayer room for Muslims and another for Jews at Dawson College, while Vanier College has a prayer room specifically for Muslims, with a curtain segregating the women from the men!

Such situations are sources of conflict. Investigators believe that “far from contributing to better coexistence, this only fuels a climate of radicalization, withdrawal into one’s community, and mutual mistrust within the CEGEP.” Furthermore, assigning a room to a particular religious group is considered “a privilege, can be seen as proselytizing, and is discriminatory toward students of other religious affiliations.” Having considered transforming the Muslim prayer room at Vanier College into a multi-religious room, that plan could not be completed due to an “acquired right” for Muslims.

So What About Secularism in CEGEPs?

“How can a prayer room be considered an acquired right in a college which must comply with articles 2 and 3 of the Act respecting the laicity of the State (Bill 21) stipulating that the principles of secularism must be respected in fact and in appearance?” the investigators rightly ask.

Indeed, although institutions of higher education are not subject to the Ministry of Education (MEQ) directive prohibiting religious practices in schools, they are nevertheless required to respect the principles of secularism, including religious neutrality. But the ambiguity persists: does religious neutrality mean accommodating all religions, or accommodating none? Concretely, in the matter of prayer spaces, should we, as the Vanier College social services officer suggests, respond to the religious requests of students of all faiths or, as the MEQ directive clearly expresses, respond to none?

In the MEQ directive, we read that “the provision of spaces for religious practices in a school […] is incompatible with the principle of religious neutrality of the State.” The ban on prayer rooms is justified in particular by respect for the freedom of conscience of students who must be protected against direct or indirect pressure inciting them to conform to a religious practice, and because such accommodations are likely to hinder the proper functioning of schools.

All these arguments are equally valid for CEGEPs. Although older than high school students, CEGEP students are mostly still minors when they arrive at the college. Furthermore, it cannot be ignored that these prayer rooms are not always places of peaceful contemplation, but sometimes become hotbeds of radicalization and recruitment centres for conflicts abroad.

Consider, for example, Maisonneuve College, which was a hotbed of student recruitment for jihad in Syria in 2015. In response to their request, the college administration provided students with a room for Friday prayers, which only fueled the climate of radicalization, community withdrawal, and mutual mistrust within the college.

In the report’s conclusion, the investigators recommend “putting in place appropriate mechanisms to ensure compliance with and application of sections 2 and 3 of the State Secularism Act.” We agree completely! But religious neutrality must also be clearly defined, not as an open door to all religious demands, but rather as the absence of any recognition of these demands and the absence of religious proselytism in CEGEPs.

And for starters, no accreditation should be granted to any student club with a religious vocation. Moreover, the legislation regulating CEGEPs makes no provision for such a contrivance.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Print This Page