- Atheist Freethinkers - https://www.atheology.ca/ -

2020-08-08: Why We Support Bill 21

AFT On-line Event, 2020-08-08

David Rand, President, Atheist Freethinkers

Publication date: 2020-08-11

This talk was accompanied by a presentation of some thirty slides [1] which we suggest you consult while reading through the text below. The video of the presentation is also available in our Youtube channel [2].

Secularism

Religious neutrality

Full Secularism

Freedom of conscience

Freedom of conscience

Bill 21: Advantages

Bill 21: Weaknesses

The ban on religious symbols is limited:

Bill 21: Weaknesses (continued)

“Laïcité” versus “Secularism”

The term “secularism” tends to be given a weaker meaning than the French word “laïcité.” The principle of religion-State separation is given lesser importance in the English word. However, this difference must not be exaggerated. The English term nevertheless includes the separation principle.

People outside Quebec who call themselves “secular” but oppose Bill 21 are extremely hypocritical. Cultural differences may explain this situation, but they do not excuse the hypocrisy. If they call themselves “secular” then they just need to be well informed and make a little intellectual effort to understand full secularism. For example, if the State allows police to wear religious symbols while on duty, then clearly the separation principle is violated. This is not difficult to understand.

Conclusion: We must stop excusing the hypocrisy and intellectual sloth of those who refuse to understand.

Constitutional Considerations

Conclusion: If the courts decide that Bill 21 violates the Charter, this will not be a moral decision, only a technical one. Maybe it is the Charter that needs to be modified or repealed, not Bill 21?

Some Guiding Principles

The Three Spaces

The Three Spaces

Bill 21: A Few Arguments in Favour (a)

To allow the wearing of religious symbols by employees in the civil service and schools:

Bill 21: A Few Arguments in Favour (b)

The ban on religious symbols is not discriminatory:

Bill 21: A Few Arguments in Favour (c)

A question of behaviour:

Bill 21: A Few Arguments in Favour (d)

When some people’s rights and freedoms collide with others’:

Bill 21: A Few Arguments in Favour (e)

Bill 21 is moderate, timid even:

Bill 21: A Few Arguments in Favour (f)

A question of professional ethics:

Bill 21: A Few Arguments in Favour (g)

The secular State is not responsible for believers’ choices:

Bill 21: The Unique Argument Against

As arguments against Bill 21 are generally very weak, opponents of the Bill often indulge in gratuitous defamatory accusations, such as accusing supporter of the Bill of “xenophobia,” “racism,” etc. However, even if all supports of Bill 21 or all Quebeckers were very xenophobic, racist, etc., that would still not be an argument against Bill 21, because it has nothing to do with race and it does not discriminate on the basis of religion.

Setting aside such defamation, I know of only one remaining argument against Bill 21 that has any plausibility: The law limits the freedom of religion (or expression, or religious expression) of civil servants and teachers.

True, but the limit is only on religious practice, not belief, and only on the job. Furthermore, this argument requires that the rights of civil service users and public school students be completely neglected, not taken into consideration.

The opponents of Bill 21 do not care at all about the rights of students and users.

We have here a situation of conflicting rights: those of employees on the one hand, and those of students and users on the other hand. We must find an equilibrium. Bill 21 finds such an equilibrium: a modest limitation on the employees rights, but only while they are on the job.

The Dishonesty of the Antisecular

The Nonsense of “Islamophobia”

Two problems:

  1. Conflation of a belief (Islam) with believers (Muslims) as we have just discussed. Anti-Muslim prejudice should be called “anti-Muslim prejudice.”
  2. To fear a religion is not necessarily an irrational phobia. It may be completely healthy. The three Abrahamic religions—Judaism, Christianity and Islam—have strong totalitarian tendencies, especially in their fundamentalist variants.

To fear religious fundamentalism is simply prudent. In fact, it is necessary.

Fake Religious Neutrality

Christian Legal Fellowship [4] (lawyers for Trinity Western University)

“While the legislation purports to be advancing ‘religious neutrality’, it does the exact opposite. By effectively banning citizens of certain faiths from public employment based on their religious expression and identity, the Bill is promoting an anti-religious public square…

But neutrality is required of the state, not individuals. State neutrality exists not to coerce irreligious uniformity, but to promote and enhance religious diversity. To paraphrase the Supreme Court, the answer is not to ban religion from the public sphere…”

Centre for Inquiry Canada [5] (claims to be “secular”)

“A truly secular society also does not give special treatment in the form of a sanction, such as Quebec’s Bill 21. People, including public sector employees, should not be treated differently if they are part of a religion. Put simply, the state must always be neutral on issues of religious belief and must not treat someone differently because of their beliefs.”

Implications of Fake Neutrality

The Toxicity of the “Woke” Mentality

Political & Philosophical Roots of “Wokism”

The woke mentality is based on a number of political and philosophical currents:

An Obsession With Minorities

Tyranny of the Majority or Tyranny of the Minority?

With regard to Bill 21, is there a “tyranny of the majority?” Yes, but not in the sense alleged by opponents of Bill 21. The tyrannical majority is the Rest-of-Canada (ROC), vilifying the minority (Quebeckers) for their progressive, secular legislation.

However, many in ROC support Bill 21, but are bullied into silence.

The tyrannical majority is allied with a tiny but very vocal tyrannical minority, Islamists. Secular Muslims are ignored.

(I define an Islamist as anyone who promotes political Islam, i.e. who attempts to obtain political power, influence or privileges for the religion Islam.)

Three Studies about Attitudes Towards Religious Symbols

  1. Antoine Bilodeau, Luc Turgeon, Stephen White and Ailsa Henderson,
    Strange Bedfellows? Attitudes toward Minority and Majority Religious Symbols in the Public Sphere [6]
    ,
    2018-03-08, Politics and Religion
    “Drawing on a survey conducted in the province of Quebec (Canada), we find that while holding liberal values and low religiosity are key characteristics of those who would ban all religious symbols, feelings of cultural threat and generalized prejudice are central characteristics of those who would only restrict minority religious symbols…”
  2. Yannick Dufresne, Anja Kilibarda, André Blais and Alexis Bibeau,
    Religiosity or racism? The bases of opposition to religious accommodation in Quebec: Religiosity or racism? [7]
    ,
    2018-08, Nations and Nationalism, Journal of the Association for the Study of Ethnicity and Nationalism
    The findings show that while opposition to religious accommodation is higher in Quebec, and higher among francophones, it is rooted more in the low level of religiosity of the francophone population than in racial animus.
  3. Luc Turgeon, Antoine Bilodeau, Stephen E. White and Ailsa Henderson,
    A Tale of Two Liberalisms? Attitudes toward Minority Religious Symbols in Quebec and Canada [8]
    ,
    2019-04-24, Canadian Journal of Political Science, Cambridge University Press
    “Our findings demonstrate that holding liberal values is associated with support for restrictions on the wearing of minority religious symbols in Quebec, but it is associated with opposition to such restrictions in the rest of Canada. Moreover, this difference between Quebec and the rest of Canada in the relationship between liberal values and support for restrictions on minority religious symbols can explain Quebecers’ greater support for restrictions.”

Summing Up

The three studies just discussed show that support for Bill 21 among Quebeckers is not correlated with racism or other illiberal attitudes.

Although this is interesting, it is irrelevant to the validity of Bill 21. Even if 100% of Quebeckers were racist or xenophobic or bigotted or whatever, Bill 21 would still be valid, progressive legislation. It is neither racist nor discriminatory.

Bill 21 is not racist because it has nothing to do with race. It deals with secularism and religion.

Bill 21 is not discriminatory because it applies to all persons and all religions equally.

Bill 21’s ban on religious symbols is a small, reasonable limit on religious practice (not belief), in order to protect the freedom of conscience of civil service users and public school students.

Conclusion

Loi 21

Quebec
is in the vanguard
of the Americas
on the issue of secularism.

Links


This article is also available as a PDF document [14].


[15] [16]