See also: In the News: Report of the Pelchat-Rousseau Committee [1]
Strengthening Secularism in Quebec
AFT has presented a brief to the Pelchat-Rousseau Committee, i.e. the Comité d’étude sur le respect des principes de la Loi sur la laïcité de l’État et sur les influences religieuses [2] (Study Committee on Compliance with the Principles of the Act respecting the laicity of the State [Bill 21] and on Religious Influences). The brief, in French, is available on our LPA website [3]. The following is a list of the recommendations made in that brief.
Date: 2025-05-16
Publication Date: 2025-05-23
Recommendations of Atheist Freethinkers
- (a) That any and all religious accommodations be eliminated from existing legislation, such as the Act to foster adherence to State religious neutrality and, in particular, to provide a framework for requests for accommodations on religious grounds in certain bodies [4], the Act respecting the laicity of the State [5] and Draft Bill 94 [6]
(b) That all future legislation refrain from granting any religious accommodation. - That the ban on wearing religious symbols in the Act respecting the laicity of the State [5] be extended to apply to all Quebec civil servants.
- That the ban on wearing religious symbols be extended to apply to all personnel of child-care centres and CEGEPs.
- That the ban on wearing face-coverings be extended to apply to all personnel of the entire Quebec educational system, both public and private, from pre-school level to university level.
- That the ban on wearing religious symbols or face-coverings be extended to all federal government employees working in Quebec.
- That the “grandfather clause” (Article 31) of the Act respecting the laicity of the State [5] be repealed.
Furthermore, in any future legislation banning the wearing of religious symbols or face-coverings, any grandfather clause must have a time limit (such as a few years) or an expiration date. - That the wearing of obvious religious symbols or face-coverings be banned for all students in primary and secondary schools.
- (a) In the Act respecting the laicity of the State, Chapter I, Article 2, as well as in the Act’s explanatory notes:
that “freedom of conscience and freedom of religion” be replaced by simply:
“freedom of conscience” or by the more explicit phrase:
“freedom of conscience, including freedom of belief, freedom of non-belief and freedom to change belief (apostasy).”
(b) That the same modification be made to Article 3 of the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms [7] and to any other legislation which uses a similar definition of secularism. - That “advancement of religion” be eliminated as criterion for charitable organizations.
- That the direct and indirect costs of tax exemptions granted to religious institutions under Articles 204 and 236 of the Act respecting Municipal Taxation [8] be accounted for and made public.
- That public funding of private schools which do not respect the secular nature of compulsory education be ended.
- That Article 215 of the Education Act [9] be amended to require that all extracurricular activities respect secularism.