- Atheist Freethinkers - https://www.atheology.ca/ -

Blog 151: Results of Our Motion to AAI

David Rand

Publication Date: 2026-01-27


At the recent assembly of Atheist Alliance International [1] (AAI) on 18th January 2026, the motion which we, AFT, presented [2], condemning the anti-secular action of CFIC, was discussed and voted on. The results: 18 against, 6 for and 2 abstentions, as well as abstention by members of the AAI Board.

Although we are of course disappointed that the motion was defeated, it nevertheless garnered some significant support. More importantly, it generated a debate of the issues, forcing CFIC to respond to some of our criticisms, something it had refused to do up until then.

CFIC has been opposing secularism in Quebec for well over a decade, all the way back to the Charter of Secularism proposed by the PQ government in 2013.

During the discussion of the motion, I pointed out that CFIC wants to have its cake and eat it too, by claiming to support secularism while abandoning the crucial principle of religion-State separation, using this as an excuse to oppose Bill 21. CFIC spokesperson Leslie Rosenblood reacted angrily, claiming that its re-definition of secularism dated to before Bill 21 was even proposed, in 2019. So what? CFIC has been opposing secularism in Quebec for well over a decade, all the way back to the Charter of Secularism proposed by the PQ government in 2013.

When I called CFIC’s opposition to Bill 21 antisecular, Mr. Rosenblood insisted on CFIC’s promotion of religious neutrality. Again, so what? For years, I have explained repeatedly that religious neutrality is not enough [3] because without separation, neutrality degenerates into a policy of allowing religions to interfere in State affairs, as long as all religions are granted the same privileges. That is precisely what happens when, for example, a judge wears an obvious religious symbol while on the bench. For complete secularism, both religious neutrality and religion-State separation are required.

I pointed out that CFIC’s antisecular action is very serious, intervening before the Supreme Court of Canada, the highest court in the land, with the goal of repealing secular legislation. Again, Mr. Rosenblood protested, pointing out that CFIC itself is not named in the intervention. This is just a technical detail. The official intervenors are the Canadian Secular (sic) Alliance (CSA) and BC Humanist Association (BCHA). The three organizations are partners. Rosenblood himself is both a CFIC Secular Chair and a CSA Policy Advisor [4]. CFIC supports CSA’s goal of repealing Bill 21.

Several of the negative votes were from Canadian organizations outside Quebec. Their unanimous opposition to Bill 21 is not surprising, given the extremely negative media coverage in Canada, misrepresenting Bill 21 as a threat to freedom of religion. Representatives of at least two of these organizations identified Bill 21’s preventive use of the notwithstanding clause as a major concern, as if that use constituted an admission that fundamental rights were being undermined (they are not). This issue is a common theme of anti-secular propaganda in Canada.

In reality, use of the notwithstanding clause is a way of attaining balance between the legislative and judicial branches. The authors of Bill 21 knew that many judges, appointed by the federal government, have serious biases, and that is undoubtedly why they invoked the notwithstanding clause. And it is a good thing that they did, because Justice Blanchard of Quebec Superior Court would have destroyed the Bill in his 2021 decision if that clause had not been invoked. Even then, he was able to suspend the application of Bill 21 to English-language schools (but fortunately the Quebec Court of Appeal restored that provision in 2024). Justice Blanchard’s biases [5] are eloquently illustrated by his criticism that Bill 21 gives no consideration to laws of “God” and by his remark that banning the wearing of religious symbols could violate the very “soul or essence” of the believer!

BCHA adopts a similarly incomplete definition of secularism [6], reducing it to mere religious neutrality. Ironically, even their definition, which declares that the State “must neither endorse nor prohibit any belief or non-belief,” is arguably incompatible with their opposition to Bill 21, because a civil servant on duty is a representative the State. If he or she wears a religious symbol, the State is implicitly endorsing that religion. But of course, that is not how BCHA and its partner organizations interpret religious neutrality. This ambiguity would be resolved if the separation principle were included in their definition of secularism, but that is exactly what they refuse to do.

Will CFIC, CSA and BCHA continue to set secularism back decades in Canada outside Quebec by opposing it both in theory (by defining it badly) and in practice (by opposing secular legislation adopted by Quebec)?

Will CFIC, CSA and BCHA continue to set secularism back decades in Canada outside Quebec by opposing it both in theory (by defining it badly) and in practice (by opposing secular legislation adopted by Quebec)? Will Mr. Rosenblood continue to erupt in self-righteous anger whenever anyone dares to point out the obvious: the hypocrisy of calling oneself secularist while opposing secularism in the very place where it is making the most progress, where legislation to protect freedom of conscience is being adopted?

At the AAI meeting, opposition to our motion criticizing CFIC’s antisecular action was based largely on the misconception that approving the motion would amount to AAI telling affiliates what their policies should be. However, the bylaws [7] clearly state that AAI’s vision is “a secular world where public policy, scientific inquiry, and education are not determined by religious beliefs” and that AAI’s mission includes speaking up “for atheist and secular interests at governmental and supranational level organisations.” Thus, by joining AAI, affiliate organizations must be aware that they are expected to support secularism. CFIC’s opposition to secular legislation is indeed incompatible with AAI’s aims. Again, any ambiguity in the bylaws would be avoided if the separation principle were explicitly mentioned.

Umbrella organizations such as AAI need to adopt a clear, coherent and complete definition of secularism, one that includes the all-important principle of separation between religions and State, promoting that definition among its affiliates and in its regular activities.

We invite everyone to read our declaration of International Solidarity with Religion-State Separation [8]. If you or your organization would like to cosign that declaration, please contact us [9].

In conclusion, I would like to put the following questions to board members of CFIC, CSA and BCHA. Consider a judge on the bench, presiding over the court.

  1. Would it be acceptable for the judge to wear a hijab, an obvious crucifix, a kippah or any other religious symbol?
  2. Would it be acceptable for the judge to wear a MAGA hat, a swastika armband, an image of Lenin, Che Guevara or Mussolini, or any other political symbol?

If the answers to these two questions are not identical—that is, neither both “Yes” nor both “No”—then I have a further question: (3) Why? Why would one be acceptable but not the other?


[10] [11]