- Atheist Freethinkers - https://www.atheology.ca/ -

Blog 149: End of an Odious Religious Privilege?

David Rand

Publication Date: 2025-12-18

2026-03-25: Update

Bill C-9, including repeal of the religious exception, was adopted by the House of Commons [1]. It is now up to the Senate to decide.

The federal Bill C-9, or the Combatting Hate Act [2], is questionable for several reasons [3]. But the bill’s worst aspect, as initially tabled on 19th September 2025, was an error of omission: that initial version left unchanged the notorious religious exception in the hate propaganda section of the Criminal Code of Canada. In point of fact, paragraphs 319(3)b et 319(3.1)b [4] declare that “No person shall be convicted of an offence” if “the person expressed or attempted to establish by an argument an opinion on a religious subject or an opinion based on a belief in a religious text.” Thus, a statement which would be considered hate speech if expressed by, say, an atheist magically becomes acceptable if asserted by a believer who manages to find a passage in “holy scripture” in support of the statement. It would be difficult to find a religious privilege more odious than that.

Recently the Carney government reached an agreement with the Bloc québécois—which had already proposed two bills in the past, each of which would have repealed that exception, both dead on the order paper—to add the repeal to Bill C-9 if the Bloc would support it. However, the Conservative Party’s outcry in response to this news frightened the government so much that it threatened to abandon the agreement. But as I write these lines, the deal seems to be on again. Nevertheless, we should wait until the law is in fact passed before declaring victory.

In its current form, this religious exception dates back to 29th April 2004, when the very brief Act to amend the Criminal Code (hate propaganda) [5] was adopted, making two amendments: (1) adding sexual orientation to the list of identifiable groups which may be targets of hate speech; and (2) strengthening the exception by inserting the reference to “an opinion based on a belief in a religious text.” At first reading in 2002, Bill C-250 [6] contained only the first amendment, but the third reading [7], adopted by the House of Commons on 17th September 2003, added the second.

The juxtaposition of these particular amendments and the late addition of (2) allow us to glimpse the motivations of the legislators at the time. If we simply consult Hansard for the debates about Bill C-250 [8], our suspicions are confirmed: the purpose of the second amendment was to calm the religious concerns of several homophobic MPs, in particular their fear that the bill would lead to recognition of same-sex marriage.

In 2017, the organization Atheist Freethinkers launched a petition, on the House of Commons website [9], calling for the repeal of the religious exception. This petition gathered more than 1500 signatures and was presented to the House in March of 2018 [10]. Unfortunately, the government of Justin Trudeau at the time rejected the petition [11] out of hand.

Today, in 2025, the opposition to repealing the religious exception echoes the objections which motivated its reinforcement more than 20 years ago.

Today, in 2025, the opposition to repealing the religious exception echoes the objections which motivated its reinforcement more than 20 years ago. According to Pierre Poilievre, repealing it would lead to the criminalization of certain passages of the bible, the quran and the torah. Poilievre’s alarmism is unjustified. To be realistic, without the religious exception, believers would no longer be able to use such a passage to obtain impunity, i.e. to be able to utter hate speech—such as calls for violence against a group such as Jews or homosexuals, etc.—using a religious text as an excuse.

In fact, a law purporting to ban hate speech but exempting religious discourse outright is of little value. Religions are a significant source, probably the most significant, of prejudice against identifiable groups, including other religious groups! Religious beliefs are not the sole cause of anti-gay prejudice, but they are its primary support.

[…] religions are often granted preferential treatment which would never be conceded to other ideologies, such as political convictions.

The oldest and most deeply ingrained of all religious prejudices is the premise that morality is necessarily based on a supernatural belief, such as belief in a god or gods. This fallacious attitude explains why atheists are so often vilified. It also explains why religions are often granted preferential treatment which would never be conceded to other ideologies, such as political convictions. Yet religions, especially theistic ones, are not systems of morality but rather systems of obedience.

This pro-religion posture may likewise explain why Canadian legislation is so riddled with religious privileges. From the “supremacy of God” in the very first line of the Constitution Act, 1982 [12], to tax exemptions, hate propaganda legislation, citizenship regulations, the office of special representative on “combatting Islamophobia” and what not, pro-religion bias is everywhere. We must rid ourselves and our laws of this unjustifiable prejudice.

In a recent editorial in Le Devoir, Brian Myles expresses concern [13] about the difficult task of distinguishing real hatred from ludicrous religious beliefs if the exception is repealed. No sir, there is no difficulty, no basic distinction to be made. Speech which is hateful and ludicrous is still hateful and ludicrous, whether religious or not.


[14] [15]