- Atheist Freethinkers - https://www.atheology.ca/ -

Blog 148: Trump’s March Towards Theocracy

David Rand

Publication Date: 2025-05-12

In two declarations dated Thursday May 1st, 2025, US President Donald Trump has moved his regime alarmingly in the direction of theocracy. He already announced that direction shortly after taking office when he established The White House Faith Office [1] by executive order.

In a Thursday May 1st proclamation [2], Trump establishes that day as “National Day of Prayer 2025,” in line with a 1988 decision by Congress recommending that the president designate the first Thursday in May of each year as National Day of Prayer. But Trump’s proclamation goes far beyond a mere one-day event, using language which sounds more like a Christian sermon than a presidential proclamation. It declares that religion and faith are essential to the history and values of the United States of America. It thanks “God for His endless blessings.” It asserts that “America has been guided by the grace of Almighty God” throughout its history and that “our greatest leaders have always recognized the necessity of faith, prayer, and devotion to God.”

The theme of Trump’s declaration is religious liberty. Yet it explicitly mentions one and only one religion, Christianity. In connection with the fight against “anti-religious bias” the proclamation mentions anti-Semitism, but not Judaism explicitly. In reality, anti-Semitic prejudice is more often ethnoracial than religious. The proclamation makes the very tendentious statement that “the true strength of the American spirit has always been found in churches, chapels, pews, parishes and synagogues, and the hearts and souls of our citizens of faith,” but that list does not include temples or mosques. There is mention of neither Islam nor Hinduism, nor any other religion.

Most significantly, there is no mention of the non-religious, thus implicitly validating the very common prejudice that everyone worthy of consideration must necessarily have a religious affiliation; that atheists are beyond the pale and atheism unmentionable. Trump declares that he “will never waver in safeguarding the right to religious liberty and protecting God in our public square.” In reading such pretentious nonsense, one marvels at the contradiction between the alleged omnipotence of “God” and his/her/its apparent need for protection—provided by Donald Trump of all people!

It is religious fanaticism in service to megalomania.

But the most disturbing aspect of Trump’s proclamation is his evocation of his survival of the assassination attempt in 2024 and his belief that “God spared my life for a reason.” This is beyond mere arrogance. It is religious fanaticism in service to megalomania.

A second declaration made the same day, “Fact Sheet: President Donald J. Trump Establishes the Religious Liberty Commission [3]” (RLC) announces the creation of that Commission and continues in a similar vein to the first declaration. Echoing an earlier executive order from February 6th [4], the emphasis is on combating so-called “anti-Christian bias.” Although such bias exists in some countries (including several Muslim-majority countries), in the USA “anti-Christian bias” exists mainly in the fevered imaginations of those with a Christian evangelical agenda. The RLC is mandated to “celebrate…religious diversity,” yet the Fact Sheet, like the National Day of Prayer proclamation, mentions neither non-Christians nor the non-religious.

The RLC will focus on, among other things, “parental rights in religious education [and] school choice” and address “emerging threats to religious liberty” by defending First Amendment rights. Recall that the First Amendment of the US Constitution [5] does not declare religion-State separation, as some mistakenly claim, but only bans the establishment of a State religion. It also puts no limit on the “free exercise” of religion, thus facilitating Trump’s pro-religious interpretation of that amendment.

The RLC declaration condemns policies “preventing parents from sending their children to religious schools, threatening funding and non-profit status for faith-based entities, and excluding religious groups from government programs.” It also re-affirms Trump’s commitment to ensure “equal access to funding for religious institutions.” This means that taxpayer funds will be funneled towards religious schools and programs. It amounts to a manifesto against religion-State fiscal separation.

The political opponents of Trump, those in the Democratic Party, are far from blameless in these matters. Democratic support for both gender pseudoscience and DEI arguably cost that party the votes of many concerned Americans who ended up voting for Trump, who promised to resolve these issues. In addition, the failure of various university administrations to take decisive measures to stem the tide of antisemitic activity—masquerading as “antizionism”—garnered further support for Trump. Indeed, the Fact Sheet announcing the establishment of the RLC explicitly refers to this issue, asserting the Trump administration’s commitment “to combat the explosion of anti-Semitism on our campuses and in our streets since October 7, 2023.”

As The Economist reminds us, “the Trump administration has science on its side [6]” in its rejection of gender ideology [7]. The Trump administration commissioned a report from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), a report which is “unexpectedly rigorous” and comparable to the Cass Review [8] in England in both quality and conclusions. In addition, Trump’s opposition to DEI programs [9] (Diversity, Equity, Inclusivity) is reasonable—or at least would be, were it not such a brutal overreaction—in light of the lack of evidence of effectiveness of DEI in reducing racism [10], as well as the irrationality of the ideologies on which DEI is founded [11].

Thus, the intellectual and ethical failures of the Democratic Party have greatly undermined their own credibility and strengthened the position of Trump and his MAGA cronies.

Thus, the intellectual and ethical failures of the Democratic Party have greatly undermined their own credibility and strengthened the position of Trump and his MAGA cronies. Thanks to the Democrats’ ineptitude, the Trump administration can now credibly claim to protect women’s and children’s rights and to oppose racism, in particular antisemitism. Both main political parties in the US have a pro-religion bias, the Republicans in favour of Christianity, the Democrats in favour of Islam.

Trump’s habit of ruling by executive order is disquieting in and of itself, as it reveals his autocratic tendencies. But much worse, these two May 1st declarations amount to a manifesto for theocracy and against secularism. There is no great surprise here, but these developments are seriously alarming.


[12] [13]