- Atheist Freethinkers - https://www.atheology.ca/ -

Proposed Quebec Constitution: Wrongfully Disparaged

This article is an English translation of the original letter, entitled Les faux procès contre le projet de constitution québécoise [1], and published in Le Devoir on 24th November 2025 [2].

Nadia El-Mabrouk

Publication Date: 2025-11-25

The proposed Bill 1, Québec Constitution Act, 2025 [3] has a unifying potential which all opposition parties should welcome.

The author is president of the Rassemblement pour la laïcité (RPL or Alliance fro Secularism). Her letter is supported by almost fifty co-signers. (See end of article.)

Although one can certainly question certain aspects of the Québec Constitution Act, the harsh criticisms published in various media against it seem to us to be largely exaggerated, or even unjustified.

Legitimacy of the process

The most frequent criticism is that of a lack of prior consultations, which would allegedly render the draft legislation illegitimate. However, given the Act’s affirmation of the collective rights of the Quebec nation and its founding principles such as secularism, the civilist nature of Quebec’s legal system or the importance it grants to equality between women and men, one cannot accuse the Act of either haste or lack of a base of popular legitimacy, because these principles stem from Quebec’s undeniable and specific historical path.

In particular, secularism is deeply rooted in the history of modern Quebec. Since the 1960s, Quebec has consistently taken steps to emancipate itself from clerical power. Before that, Quebec society was largely shaped by Christian thought and ways of life. The Parent Report brought about a radical change in this state of affairs, beginning with the creation of the Ministry of Education. To further secularize the school system, it was necessary to amend the Canadian Constitution to abolish Quebec’s constitutional obligation to maintain Catholic and Protestant education systems. This is part of what makes Quebec unique; no other province in Canada has undertaken such a secularization of its school boards.

Pushing religious power aside was not limited to education, but gradually extended to all spheres of the State, as well as to civil law. As the Pelchat-Rousseau report aptly states, “it is now known and recognized that the path taken by the State and the people of Quebec to free themselves from the religious authority of the clergy and its control over large parts of their institutions constitutes a defining characteristic of the identity of the Quebec nation.”

Draft legislation which is anything but authoritarian

The other most frequent criticism is that this Act is authoritarian. However, seeking to implement the values ​​and principles of a nation is in no way authoritarian.

The people of Quebec have long called for a model of social cohesion that differs from Canadian multiculturalism, one that focuses on integrating everyone into a shared, dynamic cultural space enriched by the contributions of Quebecers of all origins. In societies as pluralistic as Quebec’s, it is important to guide diverse social groups toward a harmonious convergence on a common vision of citizenship, without, of course, denying the cultural specificities of each.

Refusing to identify with a common national framework can only lead to social tensions and identity-based conflicts. Consider the street prayers in downtown Montreal that poison the social climate. Consider the pressure on schools to establish prayer spaces within their walls, or the daycare centres and early childhood centres that select children based on their community or religious affiliation.

These communitarian and religious tensions are largely fueled by the Canadian multiculturalism model, which encourages newcomers to identify with their community of origin rather than with the host society. This model fosters self-segregation, withdrawal into community identities and religious fundamentalism.

Conversely, secularism focuses on what is common to all, enshrining all freedoms, including religious freedoms, provided that these respect the law, are not imposed on others, and do not isolate members of certain communities from other citizens. This is not at all authoritarian. It falls within the responsibility of the State.

A necessary project

Finally, the proposed constitution is criticized for its redundancy with other laws. On the contrary, it is, in our opinion, a necessary work of synthesis, codification, and harmonization, consistent with Quebec’s civil law tradition. For example, the Act respecting the laicity of the State [4] (Bill 21) has legally enshrined the secular nature of public institutions, but tensions persist regarding the interpretation of religious neutrality between, on the one hand, the obligation to recognize all religious expression everywhere and at all times and, on the other hand, the protection of laws and regulations from any special privileges based on religious grounds.

It is important to remember that the secularization of the Quebec State occurred through a break with religious power, but also with religious morality and codes of conduct. The integration of newcomers was not achieved through the proliferation of religious symbols, but rather through their removal from public institutions. In other words, Quebec secularism was forged not by superimposing individual religious rights, but by enshrining a collective right to the religious neutrality of public institutions.

Clearly affirming secularism as a collective right of the Quebec nation in a Quebec constitution makes it possible to resolve the ambiguity inherent in the Act respecting the laicity of the State and to harmonize it with the Act respecting integration into the Quebec nation [5].

While we do not consider this Act to be a definitive or final draft of the constitution for the Quebec nation, the current text is a welcome synthesis of the fundamental values, principles, and characteristics of Quebec that are widely shared by the Quebec population. Beyond the political circumstances and issues that led to the tabling of the bill, and despite legitimate criticisms related to some of its provisions and its implementation, Bill 1 has a unifying potential which all opposition parties should welcome.

Signatories:


[6] [7]