- Atheist Freethinkers - https://www.atheology.ca/ -

Collective Letter Against the Office of Elghawaby

Amira Elghawaby’s Office does Not Facilitate Constructive Dialogue

Collective Letter with over 200 signatories

2023-02-06, petition link added 2023-03-05

This letter is also available as Parliamentary Petition e-4335 [1] which any Canadian may sign.

We, Quebecers and Canadians of all origins, women and men, wish to express our opposition not only to the nomination of Ms. Amira Elghawaby but also to the very office of special representative on combatting Islamophobia.

After displaying so much prejudice against Quebecers, Ms. Elghawaby simply does not have the moral authority to hold such a position. In order to build bridges and pursue a constructive dialogue, one must be able to inspire confidence. Her belated apology under intense political pressure seems more coerced than spontaneous.

Moreover, the fight against hate speech and hate crimes, especially against Muslims, is too important to run the risk of aggravating the situation by creating an office whose very wording is highly questionable.

Indeed, while the position for combatting antisemitism targets only racism, Islamophobia is a more militant term, overused and vaguely defined, whose usage conflates respect for the Muslim person with absolute respect for Islamic dogma. It is the very concept which most fundamentalist Islamic regimes and activists around the world are trying to get accepted in order to criminalize any “offence” to the Muslim religion. This is what earned the writer Salman Rushdie the fatwa issued by the Iranian regime ordering any Muslim anywhere to kill him, a fatwa which led to the recent brutal attack against him. It is what led to the murder of the Charlie Hebdo cartoonists as well. Ms. Elghawaby herself wrote a column in 2020 [2] in which she equated the cartoons published by Charlie Hebdo with racism. Does Canada really want to promote a woman and an office that confuses legitimate free speech with racist speech to this extent?

The wording of the position states that it will be about combatting religious intolerance. In order to be more effective and consistent in a State governed by the rule of law, we suggest instead that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau reform the Criminal Code, whose section 319, dealing with public incitement to hatred, grants impunity if such hateful speech is based on a religious opinion or text.

Furthermore, we wish to denounce the allegations that are being made, linking Quebec’s State Secularism Act to hatred of Muslims. This law does not target Muslims, and many Muslims support it. Whether one agrees or disagrees with the provisions of Bill 21, the issue of religious symbols worn by government officials and in schools is an important one in Quebec and elsewhere, including Muslim-majority countries, where debates on secularism are ongoing. It should be noted that the European Court of Human Rights has consistently validated laws similar to Bill 21.

Finally, the signatories of this letter include a large number of Canadians of Muslim background or faith, who refuse to be associated with a “Muslim community” represented moreover by people who adhere to a fundamentalist vision of Islam. Such a linkage only serves to reinforce stereotypes and prejudices against Muslims and to undermine those who live their citizenship in harmony within our liberal democracy. Moreover, we fear that this position will encourage censorship or self-censorship of any criticism of religious fundamentalism, the first victims of which are Muslims themselves.

For all these reasons, we see no benefit to this appointment or to the position itself. On the contrary, it risks aggravating tensions and generating suspicion and anger towards Muslims. We therefore ask that this position be abolished.


Signatories


[3] [4]